The condition of al-Bukhari and Muslim that al-Hakim cites: What does he intend by it?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The questioner : All right; by the way, in order to conclude our discussion of hadith, the condition of al-Bukhari and Muslim that al-Hakim cites is understood to mean that al-Bukhari and Muslim narrated them; because he says: "On their condition"?
The Shaykh : They did not narrate them.
The questioner : They did not narrate them; I mean, I intend the men, the same men.
The Shaykh : Do you mean: He narrated for them.
The questioner : He narrated for them.
The questioner : All right; I will look into it. They also specify regarding the hearing from al-Bukhari, is it authentic or not? The condition of hearing, hearing from the narrator.
The Shaykh: Yes.
The questioner : Does al-Hakim himself intend this in it, or not?
The Shaykh : What I understood from you is that you are asking and saying: If al-Hakim says: This is a chain on the condition of al-Bukhari, and one of the conditions of al-Bukhari is the establishment of hearing between each of the narrator and the one narrated from; does al-Hakim observe this when he says: On the condition of al-Bukhari? Is this your question?
Answer: They do not observe it, and this is not among his errors that are not known.
The questioner : Al-Suyuti says, perhaps he attributes to al-Hakim that he was renewing it, he was in the process of renewing it and died, so the attribution is correct because he said he found the copy?
The Shaykh : Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar also says this; meaning it was a draft and he was not given the opportunity to review it all again, and Allah knows best.
The Shaykh : They did not narrate them.
The questioner : They did not narrate them; I mean, I intend the men, the same men.
The Shaykh : Do you mean: He narrated for them.
The questioner : He narrated for them.
The questioner : All right; I will look into it. They also specify regarding the hearing from al-Bukhari, is it authentic or not? The condition of hearing, hearing from the narrator.
The Shaykh: Yes.
The questioner : Does al-Hakim himself intend this in it, or not?
The Shaykh : What I understood from you is that you are asking and saying: If al-Hakim says: This is a chain on the condition of al-Bukhari, and one of the conditions of al-Bukhari is the establishment of hearing between each of the narrator and the one narrated from; does al-Hakim observe this when he says: On the condition of al-Bukhari? Is this your question?
Answer: They do not observe it, and this is not among his errors that are not known.
The questioner : Al-Suyuti says, perhaps he attributes to al-Hakim that he was renewing it, he was in the process of renewing it and died, so the attribution is correct because he said he found the copy?
The Shaykh : Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar also says this; meaning it was a draft and he was not given the opportunity to review it all again, and Allah knows best.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.