Is the disagreement among Muslims, and especially among the Salafis, caused by the establishment of Islamic associations, or by the method of understanding the texts of the Shari'ah?

The Shaykh : Please go ahead.

The questioner: To the wordsThe Shaykh : of Abu Malik

The Shaykh: Abu Malik, yes

The questioner: The disagreement that circulates among Islamic groups, and especially among the Salafi groups, I want to understand, meaning, is the disagreement caused by the establishment of an Islamic group, or is it caused by the failure to understand the texts that support or indicate the establishment of associations, or the non-establishment of them?

The Shaykh: I did not understand the first sentence, is the disagreement caused by?

The questioner: The establishment of charitable associations

The Shaykh: Do you mean denial?
Abu Malik : Establishment

The questioner: Establishment
Abu Malik : Is the establishment

The Shaykh: Establishment
Abu Malik : Is the disagreement among Muslims, and especially among the Salafis, caused by the establishment of Islamic associations, or by the nature of understanding the texts of the Shari'ah?

The Shaykh: No, the establishment has no relation to the subject. The disagreement is fundamental, doctrinal, and intellectual, and then this disagreement gives rise to a practical disagreement. Now, regarding the associations, I think it is agreed upon among us, if Allah wills, that a charitable association must be based on the rulings of the Shari'ah. We are asking now, and I hope the answer will be clear: do you believe that every charitable association in the Islamic world is based on the rulings of the Shari'ah?

The questioner: It is possible that some are based on the rulings of the Shari'ah and some are not.

The Shaykh: Then the answer is easier, say no and the matter is over, not every.

The questioner: Not

The questioner: No, in meaning...

The Shaykh: Allow me, wait, for the best of speech is what is brief and effective

The questioner: Okay

The Shaykh: My question

The questioner : is it

The Shaykh: Is every charitable association established today in the Islamic land based on the rulings of the Shari'ah? The answer is no, not every, but rather like this and like that.

The questioner: I mean something else, like the individual Muslim

The Shaykh: Yes, the answer does not need detail, and that is why I wanted you to be concise.