Discussion of some weak hadiths.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : ... And there is [a report] that Allah has angels on earth other than the guardians. Al-Hafiz said, "This is a hadith with a good chain of narration, but it is very strange."
Al-Halabi : You discussed it with a wonderful discussion.
The Shaykh : Al-Sakhawi also graded it as good, and Al-Haythami said its narrators are trustworthy. I said, and al-Bayhaqi narrated it in "al-Shu'ab" as a mawquf, as will come. So if this hadith is authentic, it means that the intended meaning of "qawbih" in the first hadith is.
Al-Halabi : Al-Halabi : It is strange, my Shaykh, that Ahmad 'Abd al-Jalil, whom we visited recently, we named him Ahmad 'Abd al-Jalil until ...
The Shaykh : Good, so we can kill two birds with one stone.
Al-Halabi : Al-Halabi : They confused us in the session with a terrible deception. He opened the issue of istighathah, and lo, he permits it and cited as evidence, saying there is a hadith in it: andThe Shaykh : He authenticated it in al-Sahihah, the first one.
The Shaykh : I told some of the brothers, I said, no, this is found in al-Da'ifah.
The questioner : I checked, I said perhaps the matter got mixed up for me, so I checked again, and the matter is not so. And he also confused things in another matter, which is the hadith of Harithah that we weakened in "al-Iman" by Ibn Abi Shaybah, and he also saysThe Shaykh : He authenticated it. I said to him.
The Shaykh : Allah is the helper. As long as the man is my brother and follows the path of the group, authentication and weakening have become a whim.
The questioner : Now it has become by revelation.
The Shaykh : By whim. Allah is the helper.
Al-Halabi : You discussed it with a wonderful discussion.
The Shaykh : Al-Sakhawi also graded it as good, and Al-Haythami said its narrators are trustworthy. I said, and al-Bayhaqi narrated it in "al-Shu'ab" as a mawquf, as will come. So if this hadith is authentic, it means that the intended meaning of "qawbih" in the first hadith is
O servants of Allah, they are only the angels
يا عباد الله إنما هم الملائكةAl-Halabi : Al-Halabi : It is strange, my Shaykh, that Ahmad 'Abd al-Jalil, whom we visited recently, we named him Ahmad 'Abd al-Jalil until ...
The Shaykh : Good, so we can kill two birds with one stone.
Al-Halabi : Al-Halabi : They confused us in the session with a terrible deception. He opened the issue of istighathah, and lo, he permits it and cited as evidence, saying there is a hadith in it:
If one of you loses [something], let him call out, "O servants of Allah, help me"
إذا أضل أحدكم فليناد يا عبلد الله أغيثونيThe Shaykh : I told some of the brothers, I said, no, this is found in al-Da'ifah.
The questioner : I checked, I said perhaps the matter got mixed up for me, so I checked again, and the matter is not so. And he also confused things in another matter, which is the hadith of Harithah that we weakened in "al-Iman" by Ibn Abi Shaybah, and he also saysThe Shaykh : He authenticated it. I said to him.
The Shaykh : Allah is the helper. As long as the man is my brother and follows the path of the group, authentication and weakening have become a whim.
The questioner : Now it has become by revelation.
The Shaykh : By whim. Allah is the helper.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.