What is the ruling of the Shari'ah regarding legal advocacy?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : What is the ruling of the Shari'ah in your view regarding legal advocacy?
The Shaykh : Legal advocacy, which is defending the one who has a right, is permissible in principle, as it falls under the category of permissible agency. However, it is sometimes obligatory and sometimes forbidden.
Legal advocacy becomes obligatory if the right of the one who has the right cannot be extracted except through it. If your Muslim brother asks for your help to protect his wealth and to defend him against the people of oppression, it is his right upon you to assist him in this matter. It becomes forbidden if a person advocates for another to establish a falsehood or deny a right.
If a person makes legal advocacy a means to please his client, whether the client is right or wrong, then entering into it is forbidden. However, if he enters into it to support the truth and return injustices to their rightful owners, then there is no harm in it; indeed, it may be obligatory or recommended according to what the need or public benefit requires.
The questioner : May Allah bless you.
The Shaykh : Legal advocacy, which is defending the one who has a right, is permissible in principle, as it falls under the category of permissible agency. However, it is sometimes obligatory and sometimes forbidden.
Legal advocacy becomes obligatory if the right of the one who has the right cannot be extracted except through it. If your Muslim brother asks for your help to protect his wealth and to defend him against the people of oppression, it is his right upon you to assist him in this matter. It becomes forbidden if a person advocates for another to establish a falsehood or deny a right.
If a person makes legal advocacy a means to please his client, whether the client is right or wrong, then entering into it is forbidden. However, if he enters into it to support the truth and return injustices to their rightful owners, then there is no harm in it; indeed, it may be obligatory or recommended according to what the need or public benefit requires.
The questioner : May Allah bless you.