The meaning of the poet's statement: "But those who deny the Above did not agree with what is correct *** They denied the perfection of the Above for the Lord, rather they interpreted it as the decree of Allah being the highest *** not as being above the Essence"
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"But those who deny the Above did not agree with what is correct ***"
Meaning, did they not come with what is sufficient from those who deny the Above?
The student: The Mu'attilah
The Shaykh : The Jahmiyyah and the Asha'irah and the like of them, from those who deny the intrinsic elevation
"*** They denied the perfection of the Above for the Lord"
"Rather they interpreted it as the decree of Allah being the highest *** not as being above the Essence of the Merciful"
The student: ...
The Shaykh : Here, how... for this is clear from the intensity, yes, and above it is intensity
The student: For, rather they interpreted it
The Shaykh : But this writer placed the shaddah like a dot
"Rather they interpreted it as the decree of Allah being the highest *** not as being above the Essence of the Merciful"
So they interpreted the elevation with what, here?
The student: With the decree
The Shaykh : With the decree, only the meaning of elevation
"They said, and this is like the statement of people regarding *** gold that is seen from pure silver"
"It is above the type of white silver ***"
Gold is above silver, platinum is above gold, wool is above cotton, the mosque is above the market, what kind of elevation is this?
The student: The Decree
The Shaykh : The decree, they said this is the elevation of Allah, the elevation of the decree, but not the Essence
"It is above the type of white silver, not *** by essence, but in the requirement of prices"
Meaning, did they not come with what is sufficient from those who deny the Above?
The student: The Mu'attilah
The Shaykh : The Jahmiyyah and the Asha'irah and the like of them, from those who deny the intrinsic elevation
"*** They denied the perfection of the Above for the Lord"
"Rather they interpreted it as the decree of Allah being the highest *** not as being above the Essence of the Merciful"
The student: ...
The Shaykh : Here, how... for this is clear from the intensity, yes, and above it is intensity
The student: For, rather they interpreted it
The Shaykh : But this writer placed the shaddah like a dot
"Rather they interpreted it as the decree of Allah being the highest *** not as being above the Essence of the Merciful"
So they interpreted the elevation with what, here?
The student: With the decree
The Shaykh : With the decree, only the meaning of elevation
"They said, and this is like the statement of people regarding *** gold that is seen from pure silver"
"It is above the type of white silver ***"
Gold is above silver, platinum is above gold, wool is above cotton, the mosque is above the market, what kind of elevation is this?
The student: The Decree
The Shaykh : The decree, they said this is the elevation of Allah, the elevation of the decree, but not the Essence
"It is above the type of white silver, not *** by essence, but in the requirement of prices"
