The Book of Hajj-09a
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The reciter: And Muhammad ibn Bashar narrated it to us, saying: Muhammad, meaning ibn Ja'far, narrated to us, and Shu'bah narrated to us with this chain, except that he said: And among those who did not have the sacrificial animal with them were Talhah ibn 'Ubayd Allah and another man, so they exited the state of ihram.
This contradicts the first one, because it says that Talhah did not have the sacrificial animal with him, whereas the first one says: So Talhah was among those who brought the sacrificial animal, so did he not exit the state of ihram?
The Shaykh : So Talhah was among those who brought the sacrificial animal, and nothing was mentioned regarding this, to the point that in my view, nothing was mentioned that requires consideration.
Who will volunteer for this?
This contradicts the first one, because it says that Talhah did not have the sacrificial animal with him, whereas the first one says: So Talhah was among those who brought the sacrificial animal, so did he not exit the state of ihram?
The Shaykh : So Talhah was among those who brought the sacrificial animal, and nothing was mentioned regarding this, to the point that in my view, nothing was mentioned that requires consideration.
Who will volunteer for this?