How do we reconcile the narration of the sale of the camel with the narration of the gift?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : ... Jabir’s narration of the hadith ... the second narration indicates that the first was ... and the second narration ...
The Shaykh : No, there is no explicit statement that he is giving it as a gift. That is why we mentioned that his saying “it is yours” means after the sale was completed. However, the second meaning of “it is yours” is that he intended to give it to him as a gift. Therefore, we needed to review the commentary. Perhaps our brother Ali, where is he? Can you clarify this for us? Yes, very well.
The Shaykh : No, there is no explicit statement that he is giving it as a gift. That is why we mentioned that his saying “it is yours” means after the sale was completed. However, the second meaning of “it is yours” is that he intended to give it to him as a gift. Therefore, we needed to review the commentary. Perhaps our brother Ali, where is he? Can you clarify this for us? Yes, very well.