What is the reason for demanding proof regarding the one who killed the slain?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Demanding proof regarding the one who killed the slain in the context of the spoils?
The Shaykh : So that no one claims he killed him when he did not kill him.
The questioner : I mentioned two opinions.
The Shaykh : We mentioned two opinions: is this a legislative ruling or an organizational arrangement? If it is a legislative ruling, it means the spoils are established for him whether the commander assigned them to him or not. And if we say it is an organizational arrangement, it is not established for the killer unless the commander says so. Is that clear? Do you understand? Good.
The Shaykh : So that no one claims he killed him when he did not kill him.
The questioner : I mentioned two opinions.
The Shaykh : We mentioned two opinions: is this a legislative ruling or an organizational arrangement? If it is a legislative ruling, it means the spoils are established for him whether the commander assigned them to him or not. And if we say it is an organizational arrangement, it is not established for the killer unless the commander says so. Is that clear? Do you understand? Good.