His saying, the Exalted: “So he looked and saw him in the midst of the Blazing Fire.” Did this happen only once?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The student: ...
The Shaykh : And it appears that he sees it until there is a debate between them.
The student: ...only once?
The Shaykh : Whenever he wished? As for the verse, Allah mentioned it only once in it, and Allah knows best. Does the showing of the vision occur every time people gather with them, or is it a single instance where he speaks of Allah’s favor with this man and it ends?
The Shaykh : And it appears that he sees it until there is a debate between them.
The student: ...only once?
The Shaykh : Whenever he wished? As for the verse, Allah mentioned it only once in it, and Allah knows best. Does the showing of the vision occur every time people gather with them, or is it a single instance where he speaks of Allah’s favor with this man and it ends?