Does the apposition of explanation fall within the definition of substitution, and what is excluded from the followers through the definition?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : So, does anything other than apposition fall in?
The Shaykh : What is it?
The questioner : The apposition of explanation falls in.
The Shaykh : All of them fall in, except the apposition with *bal*; he excluded it by his statement: "without an intermediary".
The questioner : Are there differences in it?
The Shaykh : No, my brother, because "without an intermediary" excludes only the apposition with *bal*. As for the intended meaning of the ruling, it includes all the particles of conjunction. Yes, they fall in; it includes all the particles of conjunction, and it also includes the adjective and the apposition of explanation.
But his statement: "without an intermediary": what is excluded in it is only the conjoined with *bal*. Now, if I say: "Zayd stood up, but 'Umar," the intended meaning now is to inform of 'Umar's standing, but through an intermediary, which is: *bal*. So that would not be a substitute because it is through an intermediary.
The Shaykh : What is it?
The questioner : The apposition of explanation falls in.
The Shaykh : All of them fall in, except the apposition with *bal*; he excluded it by his statement: "without an intermediary".
The questioner : Are there differences in it?
The Shaykh : No, my brother, because "without an intermediary" excludes only the apposition with *bal*. As for the intended meaning of the ruling, it includes all the particles of conjunction. Yes, they fall in; it includes all the particles of conjunction, and it also includes the adjective and the apposition of explanation.
But his statement: "without an intermediary": what is excluded in it is only the conjoined with *bal*. Now, if I say: "Zayd stood up, but 'Umar," the intended meaning now is to inform of 'Umar's standing, but through an intermediary, which is: *bal*. So that would not be a substitute because it is through an intermediary.