Is pointing with the finger prescribed between the two prostrations?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Is there a pointing with the finger between the two prostrations? Given that there are hadiths regarding this, if there are indeed hadiths.
Answer:
What is preserved in the two tashahhuds is pointing with the finger in the two tashahhuds.
As for what is narrated regarding between the two prostrations: what appears to me is that it is anomalous, contradicting the authentic hadiths. It is narrated from Wail with a sound chain regarding between the two prostrations, but it appears to be anomalous; because when a trustworthy narrator contradicts the trustworthy ones, his report becomes anomalous. So what is known in the authentic hadiths is that between the two prostrations, one spreads his hands on his thighs and knees, and it is not a place for pointing. Rather, the pointing is in the tashahhuds. This is what is preserved from the authentic hadiths.
Is there a pointing with the finger between the two prostrations? Given that there are hadiths regarding this, if there are indeed hadiths.
Answer:
What is preserved in the two tashahhuds is pointing with the finger in the two tashahhuds.
As for what is narrated regarding between the two prostrations: what appears to me is that it is anomalous, contradicting the authentic hadiths. It is narrated from Wail with a sound chain regarding between the two prostrations, but it appears to be anomalous; because when a trustworthy narrator contradicts the trustworthy ones, his report becomes anomalous. So what is known in the authentic hadiths is that between the two prostrations, one spreads his hands on his thighs and knees, and it is not a place for pointing. Rather, the pointing is in the tashahhuds. This is what is preserved from the authentic hadiths.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.