If a man prays with the women of his household, whether traveling or resident, is it permissible for them to raise their voices when saying the ameen, and what is the ruling if there are men with them who are not mahram?

The questioner : If I pray with the women of my household, whether traveling or resident, is it permissible for them to raise their voices when saying the ameen? And if the ruling is that it is permissible, is it also permissible if there are men with us who are not mahram to them?

The Shaykh : A woman does not raise her voice with any of the dhikr for which it is prescribed to raise the voice. So in the talbiyah, she does not raise her voice; in the dhikr after prayer, she does not raise her voice; and in saying the ameen, she does not raise her voice. This is the well-known ruling regarding the woman, whether there are men with her or not. Accordingly, if you pray with your family in a prayer where the recitation is loud and you say: , then you say the ameen and raise your voice with it, but your female family members do not raise their voices with it.