I am a teacher and I am forced to distribute questions and supervise the students, and I have more than one case: First: If I say to a specific student: Re-solve the question.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : He says: May the Shaykh be respected, I am a teacher, I am a teacher and I am forced to distribute questions and supervise the students, and I have more than one case, First: If I say to a specific student: Re-solve the question, is this cheating?
The Shaykh : ... How?
The questioner : He says if I say to a specific student: Re-solve the question...
The Shaykh : Specific?
The questioner : I mean a particular person.
The Shaykh : I mean a specific one.
The questioner : Re-solve the question, is this considered cheating? Second: If I say to the student: Look at this question, is it correct?
In order to draw his attention to re-solving the question because he made a mistake in it.
Third: If I make the statement general for all students without specifying, what is the ruling on the three cases?
The Shaykh : All of this is cheating, whether you say: Look at the answer, or look at the question, generally or specifically, except if the question is ambiguous, then it is obligatory to clarify it for the student, but if the question is clear, then pointing to the answer is considered cheating. Yes, that is right.
We are finished now, only two questions, no, this is long, we will conclude.
I always like for people to leave saying, "I wish we had more," not that they leave saying, "It was too long for us."
The questioner : He says: May the Shaykh be respected, is there a scholarly course in this mosque, or will it move to Makkah as we heard, and when does it start if there is a scholarly course here? I ask for clarification so that we can arrange our affairs.
The Shaykh : I was thinking that we would spend the vacation in Makkah, but I changed my mind, so the vacation will be, if Allah wills, here, and it will start on the tenth of the coming month, if Allah wills, because I think it will enter on Thursday, the month of Rabi' al-Awwal, Thursday the 8th, and Friday the 9th, and Saturday the 10th, if Allah wills, the studies will begin, with Allah's permission.
The Shaykh : ... How?
The questioner : He says if I say to a specific student: Re-solve the question...
The Shaykh : Specific?
The questioner : I mean a particular person.
The Shaykh : I mean a specific one.
The questioner : Re-solve the question, is this considered cheating? Second: If I say to the student: Look at this question, is it correct?
In order to draw his attention to re-solving the question because he made a mistake in it.
Third: If I make the statement general for all students without specifying, what is the ruling on the three cases?
The Shaykh : All of this is cheating, whether you say: Look at the answer, or look at the question, generally or specifically, except if the question is ambiguous, then it is obligatory to clarify it for the student, but if the question is clear, then pointing to the answer is considered cheating. Yes, that is right.
We are finished now, only two questions, no, this is long, we will conclude.
I always like for people to leave saying, "I wish we had more," not that they leave saying, "It was too long for us."
The questioner : He says: May the Shaykh be respected, is there a scholarly course in this mosque, or will it move to Makkah as we heard, and when does it start if there is a scholarly course here? I ask for clarification so that we can arrange our affairs.
The Shaykh : I was thinking that we would spend the vacation in Makkah, but I changed my mind, so the vacation will be, if Allah wills, here, and it will start on the tenth of the coming month, if Allah wills, because I think it will enter on Thursday, the month of Rabi' al-Awwal, Thursday the 8th, and Friday the 9th, and Saturday the 10th, if Allah wills, the studies will begin, with Allah's permission.