Some young people submit a request to a specific entity to help them with marriage, for example. Is this contrary to the hadith:
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The point is that in the case where some young people, for example, as we hear, they say, by Allah, in a committee or something, that helps those who are getting married, helps people who have, for example, an interest, they go, by Allah, and write a contract, by Allah, that so-and-so wants to get married, or I want to get married... What do you think of this point? This point seems to be without supervision.
The Shaykh : No, no... if you said without supervision, that would be better, worse than supervision.
The questioner : Worse than supervision.
The Shaykh : There is no doubt this is worse. This isSunan Ibn Majah 1837Sahih (Darussalam) ... there is a prohibition against this. This is also a problem that...
Today the boy... is in school and the world, and studies, for example... and gets a certificate so that they ask... and as soon as he gets a certificate, he submits a formal request. All of this is contrary to the Prophetic guidance.
The Shaykh : No, no... if you said without supervision, that would be better, worse than supervision.
The questioner : Worse than supervision.
The Shaykh : There is no doubt this is worse. This is
Do not ask people for anything.
لا تسأل الناس شيئاًToday the boy... is in school and the world, and studies, for example... and gets a certificate so that they ask... and as soon as he gets a certificate, he submits a formal request. All of this is contrary to the Prophetic guidance.