After my arrival from Muzdalifah in one of the years, I stoned the Jamrat al-Aqabah, then the second, then the third, because I was not sure which of the pillars was which. Is there anything required of me for that?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : After my arrival from Muzdalifah in one of the years, I stoned the Jamrat al-Aqabah, then the second, then the third, because I was not sure which of the pillars was which. Is there anything required of me for that? He says: And on the second day, I did as I did on the day of the festival, and I did not start with the pillar closest to the Holy Mosque, but rather I started with the one closest to Mina. Is there anything required of me for that as well?
The Shaykh : Praise be to Allah. As for your stoning of the three pillars on the day of the festival, only the stoning of the Jamrat al-Aqabah was valid, because that is the one that is stoned on the day of the festival. The stoning of the middle and the lower pillar was invalid. As for your stoning of the three pillars on the two following days, and your starting with the pillar closest to Mina, that is the correct procedure. Indeed, a person on the day of the festival does not stone except one pillar, which is the Jamrat al-Aqabah. And on the days following it, he stones the three pillars, starting with the first pillar closest to Mina, then the middle one, then the Jamrat al-Aqabah closest to Makkah. Yes.
The questioner : This message is from the brother, the sender, Shukri ibn 'Ali ibn Mughram or Mu'zam al-Bakri, from al-Nammas, from Banu Bakr. He says in this message: I am sending you this message, which contains a question that concerns me, and I wish for an explanation of the solution to this question and for the response to be sent or broadcast, if you would be so kind.
The Shaykh : Praise be to Allah. As for your stoning of the three pillars on the day of the festival, only the stoning of the Jamrat al-Aqabah was valid, because that is the one that is stoned on the day of the festival. The stoning of the middle and the lower pillar was invalid. As for your stoning of the three pillars on the two following days, and your starting with the pillar closest to Mina, that is the correct procedure. Indeed, a person on the day of the festival does not stone except one pillar, which is the Jamrat al-Aqabah. And on the days following it, he stones the three pillars, starting with the first pillar closest to Mina, then the middle one, then the Jamrat al-Aqabah closest to Makkah. Yes.
The questioner : This message is from the brother, the sender, Shukri ibn 'Ali ibn Mughram or Mu'zam al-Bakri, from al-Nammas, from Banu Bakr. He says in this message: I am sending you this message, which contains a question that concerns me, and I wish for an explanation of the solution to this question and for the response to be sent or broadcast, if you would be so kind.