Do sins break the fast? And does mere ejaculation without intercourse break the fast by analogy with vomiting?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : ... one person, for example, backbit me, backbit me while I was fasting, so he committed a forbidden act or lied, or did any of the sins; he is sinful, but this has no effect on the fast.
Another questioner: I mean, the evidence ... is fasting outside this topic?
The Shaykh: Certainly; I mean, we do not have in the Shari'ah anything that obligates the Muslim to make up a day because of mere ejaculation.
The questioner: ... about vomiting in Ramadan.
The Shaykh: On what?
The questioner: On the one who vomits in Ramadan;Bulugh al-Maram 5:22.
The Shaykh: Yes.
This is a text, this is a text on the topic of vomiting.
The questioner: Yes.
The Shaykh: Okay, what is the operative cause of the analogy?
The questioner: He said that ... that vomiting in their school leads to the weakness of the person ... so likewise ejaculation leads to weakness.
The Shaykh: Ejaculation leads to weakness?
The questioner: Ejaculation leads to weakness.
The Shaykh: On the contrary [the Shaykh laughs!], this is as Ibn Hazm says - of course we agree with him on part of his speech and disagree with him as a principle -; he says: "All analogy is invalid, and if there is any truth in it, this is the very essence of falsehood"; how is this to be analogized to this? Besides, does Lady Aisha not know analogy?
The questioner: ... when she was asked ... she said: "And which of you can control his desire?"
The Shaykh: You did not answer me! As usual, I mean!!
Does Lady Aisha not know this analogy?
The questioner: By Allah, I do not know!
The Shaykh: How do you not know? Or if I made a mistake in the question, we will develop it; so that you come to know it with me; does Lady Aisha know how to do analogy?
The questioner: Without a doubt, no doubt that she does.
The Shaykh: There, you have come to know it, and praise be to Allah! So when she said that it does not break the fast except intercourse, did she hit the mark in this analogy ...?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : May Allah have mercy on you.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : Yes?
The questioner: Except intercourse.
The Shaykh: Of course, did nothing else overcome you?
The questioner: It seems this is not.
The Shaykh: Until this hour?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Allah is the Greatest! And have you not read "al-Silsilah"?
The questioner: A complete part ... .
The Shaykh: In any case, these are the movements of your Shaykh!
Another questioner: This ... the one who asked him, and only.
The Shaykh: He ... is from the movements of that one.
Another questioner: He who asked said ... .
The Shaykh: This is his example as he said.
Another questioner: Your question is as follows: If a person.
The Shaykh: As the old Arabic proverb says: The wall said to the nail: Why do you split me? It said: Ask the one who drives me. So ask Abu 'Asim: Who drives him?!
Another questioner: This ... Abu 'Asim who drives me ... .
...
The Shaykh: All of this has no basis.
Another questioner: Allah is the Greatest!
The Shaykh: Except the last hadith, and even that is weak.
Another questioner : May Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh: Or weaker than weak.
Another questioner: I mean, the evidence ... is fasting outside this topic?
The Shaykh: Certainly; I mean, we do not have in the Shari'ah anything that obligates the Muslim to make up a day because of mere ejaculation.
The questioner: ... about vomiting in Ramadan.
The Shaykh: On what?
The questioner: On the one who vomits in Ramadan;
Whoever is overcome and vomits is not to make up for the day, but whoever vomits intentionally must make up the day.
مَن ذَرَعَه القيءُ فلا شيء عليه ، ومَن استقاء فعليه القضاءThe Shaykh: Yes.
This is a text, this is a text on the topic of vomiting.
The questioner: Yes.
The Shaykh: Okay, what is the operative cause of the analogy?
The questioner: He said that ... that vomiting in their school leads to the weakness of the person ... so likewise ejaculation leads to weakness.
The Shaykh: Ejaculation leads to weakness?
The questioner: Ejaculation leads to weakness.
The Shaykh: On the contrary [the Shaykh laughs!], this is as Ibn Hazm says - of course we agree with him on part of his speech and disagree with him as a principle -; he says: "All analogy is invalid, and if there is any truth in it, this is the very essence of falsehood"; how is this to be analogized to this? Besides, does Lady Aisha not know analogy?
The questioner: ... when she was asked ... she said: "And which of you can control his desire?"
The Shaykh: You did not answer me! As usual, I mean!!
Does Lady Aisha not know this analogy?
The questioner: By Allah, I do not know!
The Shaykh: How do you not know? Or if I made a mistake in the question, we will develop it; so that you come to know it with me; does Lady Aisha know how to do analogy?
The questioner: Without a doubt, no doubt that she does.
The Shaykh: There, you have come to know it, and praise be to Allah! So when she said that it does not break the fast except intercourse, did she hit the mark in this analogy ...?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : May Allah have mercy on you.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : Yes?
The questioner: Except intercourse.
The Shaykh: Of course, did nothing else overcome you?
The questioner: It seems this is not.
The Shaykh: Until this hour?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Allah is the Greatest! And have you not read "al-Silsilah"?
The questioner: A complete part ... .
The Shaykh: In any case, these are the movements of your Shaykh!
Another questioner: This ... the one who asked him, and only.
The Shaykh: He ... is from the movements of that one.
Another questioner: He who asked said ... .
The Shaykh: This is his example as he said.
Another questioner: Your question is as follows: If a person.
The Shaykh: As the old Arabic proverb says: The wall said to the nail: Why do you split me? It said: Ask the one who drives me. So ask Abu 'Asim: Who drives him?!
Another questioner: This ... Abu 'Asim who drives me ... .
...
The Shaykh: All of this has no basis.
Another questioner: Allah is the Greatest!
The Shaykh: Except the last hadith, and even that is weak.
Another questioner : May Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh: Or weaker than weak.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.