Discussion of the Hadith: (The Hour will not be established while there is on the face of the earth anyone who says: Allah, Allah)

The Shaykh : What is the meaning of: ? That is: whoever says: There is no god but Allah; and the evidence for this is that this same hadith, which Muslim narrated from Anas in this concise wording: , Imam Ahmad narrated it with a sound chain according to the conditions of Muslim in the wording: ; so this is another narration that explained the first narration.
I once debated some of the Naqshbandi shaykhs about this hadith, when I asked him where you came from with what you call the singular dhikr "Allah, Allah, Allah"? Especially these Naqshbandis, they remember with their hearts as we hinted to you earlier. He said: Did not the Messenger (peace be upon him) say: ?! I said to him: Yes, but I ask you: Is the dhikr with the wording "Allah, Allah" obligatory? He said: No. Is it required? He said: No. We said to him: Is it a confirmed sunnah? He said: No. I said to him: So the most it deserves in rank is that it be recommended, and that the dhikr of others is better, but it is like dhikr, meaning its best state is that it be recommended. He said: Yes, that is right. I said to him: What is your opinion if the Muslim community agreed to perform everything that Allah has made obligatory upon them of obedience, obligations, sunnahs, and recommendations, and left this one recommendation; would the Hour be established for them? He said: No. I said to him: But if they associate partners with Allah and worship other than Allah, do they not deserve the establishment of the Hour? He said: Yes. I said: And therefore he (peace be upon him) said: , so if these Muslims preserve all the obediences and acts of worship, and leave the dhikr of "Allah, Allah"; do they become the most wretched of people, and deserve the establishment of the Hour for them? The man was stunned, and he spoke words that we do not now admire in terms of the method of research and discussion, this is very clear.
"Allah, Allah" is dhikr, well, if the Muslims left this dhikr, does it mean they deserve that the Hour be established for them, meaning they became the worst of creation? No, the worst of creation are those who associate partners with Allah, and do not say: "There is no god but Allah," for these the Hour is established.
The conclusion: It is obligatory always and forever that the texts be interpreted in light of the reality of the life of the Messenger (peace be upon him) and the life of the righteous Salaf; just as I gave you this example, meaning it clarifies the issue for you and relieves your minds of many difficulties and doubts. Come, let us pray two rak'ahs for Allah in congregation, what is in it, brothers? I do not know, there is a look, what is the look? What the Salaf did not do! All these innovations that we deny, the Salaf did not do them, .

The questioner : ... .

The Shaykh: Complete, estimated this ... .

The questioner: It is estimated.

Eid Abbasi: Meaning it is used in the language sometimes as a context, and the context indicates something estimated ... .

Another questioner : ... ... .

Eid Abbasi: That there is no question here of a context or anything ... .