Does blood coming out of a man break the fast?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : And blood coming out of a man?
The Shaykh : Blood coming out?
The questioner : Blood coming out of a man, not a woman. If a woman has menstruation or blood coming out of her, and a man is in the same situation, meaning due to bleeding in the bladder, may Allah protect us and you, or in the stomach, or hemorrhoids, or something like that.
The Shaykh : Your question relates to the nullifiers of wudu' or to fasting.
The questioner : The nullifiers of wudu'.
The Shaykh : Okay, the blood that comes out of a woman is either menstrual blood or irregular non-menstrual bleeding, right?
The questioner : Or blood due to an illness, like an ulcer or ... .
The Shaykh : It is not important, but the location has an effect regarding the woman, because you said that this did not come out as menstrual blood or irregular non-menstrual bleeding, correct? If it is not menstrual blood, then it is irregular non-menstrual bleeding, and this nullifies the wudu'. As for the man, since it is not his custom to menstruate or have irregular non-menstrual bleeding, the ruling on his blood is different from the ruling on the blood of a woman who menstruates or has irregular non-menstrual bleeding. Therefore, in the Shafi'i school, in this point, it is the most lenient of the schools, as it states that blood coming out does not nullify the wudu' no matter how much it is. Its opposite is the Hanafi school, which states that it nullifies the wudu' no matter how little it is. The middle position is the school of Imam Ahmad and also Malik: if it is a lot, it nullifies, otherwise it does not. And I do not imagine, in the usual case, that a man would have a lot of blood, more than the story of that guard who stood guarding the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) and the group while they were sleeping during a journey ... .
The Shaykh : Blood coming out?
The questioner : Blood coming out of a man, not a woman. If a woman has menstruation or blood coming out of her, and a man is in the same situation, meaning due to bleeding in the bladder, may Allah protect us and you, or in the stomach, or hemorrhoids, or something like that.
The Shaykh : Your question relates to the nullifiers of wudu' or to fasting.
The questioner : The nullifiers of wudu'.
The Shaykh : Okay, the blood that comes out of a woman is either menstrual blood or irregular non-menstrual bleeding, right?
The questioner : Or blood due to an illness, like an ulcer or ... .
The Shaykh : It is not important, but the location has an effect regarding the woman, because you said that this did not come out as menstrual blood or irregular non-menstrual bleeding, correct? If it is not menstrual blood, then it is irregular non-menstrual bleeding, and this nullifies the wudu'. As for the man, since it is not his custom to menstruate or have irregular non-menstrual bleeding, the ruling on his blood is different from the ruling on the blood of a woman who menstruates or has irregular non-menstrual bleeding. Therefore, in the Shafi'i school, in this point, it is the most lenient of the schools, as it states that blood coming out does not nullify the wudu' no matter how much it is. Its opposite is the Hanafi school, which states that it nullifies the wudu' no matter how little it is. The middle position is the school of Imam Ahmad and also Malik: if it is a lot, it nullifies, otherwise it does not. And I do not imagine, in the usual case, that a man would have a lot of blood, more than the story of that guard who stood guarding the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) and the group while they were sleeping during a journey ... .
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
