Is there a narration regarding the issue of moving the finger during the tashahhud, "he used to move it vigorously"?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Is there a narration that he used to move it vigorously?
The Shaykh : There is no narration at all, neither vigorously nor without vigor. There is no such narration; there is nothing except what you heard just now: "So I saw him moving it, making du'a with it". However, I mentioned in the footnote or in the commentary on the description of prayer a report from Imam Ahmad that he raised it vigorously. This is the statement of Imam Ahmad, not a hadith. Pay attention, my brother, to the questioner's question... The answer is that we say this is an athar from Imam Ahmad that he raised it vigorously, so it is not a hadith traced to the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him).
The Shaykh : There is no narration at all, neither vigorously nor without vigor. There is no such narration; there is nothing except what you heard just now: "So I saw him moving it, making du'a with it". However, I mentioned in the footnote or in the commentary on the description of prayer a report from Imam Ahmad that he raised it vigorously. This is the statement of Imam Ahmad, not a hadith. Pay attention, my brother, to the questioner's question... The answer is that we say this is an athar from Imam Ahmad that he raised it vigorously, so it is not a hadith traced to the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him).