(Explanation of the followers' contradiction of the imams in this matter) You contradicted the words of the Shaykhs and His word*** So you have two followers who agree, and by Allah, your affair is strange and astonishing*** Two opposites in you
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"You contradicted the words of the Shaykhs and His word" means you did not take their advice; you preferred the words of the Shaykhs to His word and contradicted His word.
"So you have two followers who agree"
What are they? Contradicting the Shaykhs who advised following the Messenger and setting aside their words, and contradicting the Messenger where they contradicted His word for the sake of their Shaykhs' words.
"And by Allah, your affair is strange and astonishing*** Two opposites in you who do not agree"
Truly, their affair is strange. They prefer the words of the Shaykhs while they forbid them from preferring their words. This is strange and astonishing, meaning it astonishes a person; it is strange in itself and also astonishing, so everyone who knows of it is astonished by it. Yes.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : Your Shaykhs, with a dammah.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : Your Shaykhs advised you to contradict them, meaning to contradict them. Yes, they said: If the Messenger says something and we say something, contradict our words and agree with the word of the Messenger.
"So you have two followers who agree"
What are they? Contradicting the Shaykhs who advised following the Messenger and setting aside their words, and contradicting the Messenger where they contradicted His word for the sake of their Shaykhs' words.
"And by Allah, your affair is strange and astonishing*** Two opposites in you who do not agree"
Truly, their affair is strange. They prefer the words of the Shaykhs while they forbid them from preferring their words. This is strange and astonishing, meaning it astonishes a person; it is strange in itself and also astonishing, so everyone who knows of it is astonished by it. Yes.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : Your Shaykhs, with a dammah.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : Your Shaykhs advised you to contradict them, meaning to contradict them. Yes, they said: If the Messenger says something and we say something, contradict our words and agree with the word of the Messenger.