(Discussion of valid analogical reasoning and defective analogical reasoning) And our discussion is about it, and our discussion is not*** about anything else, namely the second type of analogical reasoning, which does not contradict an explicit text, so the people
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : Every analogical reasoning that contradicts an explicit text is a false, rejected, and invalid explicit text
"And our discussion is about it" means about the analogical reasoning that contradicts the explicit text
"And our discussion is not*** about anything else, namely the second type of analogical reasoning
which does not contradict an explicit text"
Meaning, we invalidate the analogical reasoning that contradicts the explicit text, as for the second type of analogical reasoning which does not contradict the explicit text, we do not deny it
"So the people have*** acted upon it in all times"
But he said, may Allah have mercy on him.
"And our discussion is about it" means about the analogical reasoning that contradicts the explicit text
"And our discussion is not*** about anything else, namely the second type of analogical reasoning
which does not contradict an explicit text"
Meaning, we invalidate the analogical reasoning that contradicts the explicit text, as for the second type of analogical reasoning which does not contradict the explicit text, we do not deny it
"So the people have*** acted upon it in all times"
But he said, may Allah have mercy on him.