Chapter on what was transmitted that all of 'Arafah is a standing place
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The reciter: Chapter on what was transmitted that all of 'Arafah is a standing place.
The Shaykh : With this construction,Muwatta Malik 20:179 two interpretations are permissible:
That all of 'Arafah is a standing place, with "all" serving as an emphasis for 'Arafah, or "all" with a dammah, serving as the subject, with what follows it as the predicate, and the sentence as the predicate of . Which of the two is more appropriate?
The first is more appropriate, because if you make "all" nominative as a subject, it becomes a compound of two sentences, and the default is to avoid such construction. Yes.
The Shaykh : With this construction,
the whole of Arafa is a standing-place
أن عرفة كلها موقفThat all of 'Arafah is a standing place, with
Every
كلEvery
كلIndeed
إنThe first is more appropriate, because if you make "all" nominative as a subject, it becomes a compound of two sentences, and the default is to avoid such construction. Yes.