What is the difference between the innovation that leads to open sinfulness and the Jahmiyyah?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Since innovation is divided into two categories, what is the limit of the innovation that leads to disbelief as opposed to the one that leads to open sinfulness?
The Shaykh : This depends on the specific innovation; one must look into it. For example, the innovation of the Jahmiyyah leads to disbelief, the innovation of those who misguide all the Companions leads to disbelief, and the innovation of those who deny seeing Allah in the Hereafter leads to disbelief. However, declaring each specific case to be disbelief requires verification. Yes.
The Shaykh : This depends on the specific innovation; one must look into it. For example, the innovation of the Jahmiyyah leads to disbelief, the innovation of those who misguide all the Companions leads to disbelief, and the innovation of those who deny seeing Allah in the Hereafter leads to disbelief. However, declaring each specific case to be disbelief requires verification. Yes.