Reading from the author's words with commentary and collation of manuscripts: "As for the detailed answer, we say: The crux of this doubt rests on two principles: transmitted,
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The reader: "As for the detailed answer, we say: The crux of this doubt rests on two principles: transmitted, which is what is reported of the practice of this supplication by some notable figures.
And rational, which is what is believed of its benefit through experience and syllogisms.
As for the transmission in this matter: it is either a lie, or an error, or not a proof; rather, we have mentioned the transmission from those who are to be followed, which is to the contrary.
And as for the rational".
The student: Questions.
The Shaykh : Yes? Questions. Fine, no one has asked.
And rational, which is what is believed of its benefit through experience and syllogisms.
As for the transmission in this matter: it is either a lie, or an error, or not a proof; rather, we have mentioned the transmission from those who are to be followed, which is to the contrary.
And as for the rational".
The student: Questions.
The Shaykh : Yes? Questions. Fine, no one has asked.