Do we abandon a narrator's hadith if al-Bukhari described him in the biographical section as having denounced narrations?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : In the biographical section, al-Bukhari says so-and-so has denounced narrations. Do we abandon the narrator's hadith?
The Shaykh : If there is no one contradicting him with opinions that are stronger than the Imam's opinion, then it is necessary to abandon it. Now, this is my turn to tighten the connection. It is not like that. I put it in the dirt and it got full of dirt. Now, may Allah guide you, why did you do this? When I lifted it up, the dirt came out of it, and I was watching.
The student : ... There is an engineer here who is following you, yes, my Shaykh.
Another student: ...
The student : It is not required for you to review it, heh heh.
The Shaykh : What do you want now?
The student : Muhammad, if you are intending to shorten it, my Shaykh, replace it with one that is a bit longer.
The Shaykh : Is that it?
The student : Yes, this is instead of him unfastening it.
The Shaykh : Why?
The student : So that it is flush against the wall, what do you think? Because he wants to unfasten it, and we have pipe pieces.
Another student : ...
The student : No ... the tank is done. Now, a piece comes here, look, yes, three-quarters of it, go look at it, Muhammad, yes, it is toothed.
Another student : ...
The student : All right, okay, okay, so that...
Another student: ... so that you can bring it from behind.
The student : All right, okay, rely on Allah.
Another student: From behind this same line.
The student : All right, okay.
Another student: ... unless we bring it.
The student : Glory be to Allah, if the water were available, he would do everything quickly, but the problem is...
The Shaykh : If there is no one contradicting him with opinions that are stronger than the Imam's opinion, then it is necessary to abandon it. Now, this is my turn to tighten the connection. It is not like that. I put it in the dirt and it got full of dirt. Now, may Allah guide you, why did you do this? When I lifted it up, the dirt came out of it, and I was watching.
The student : ... There is an engineer here who is following you, yes, my Shaykh.
Another student: ...
The student : It is not required for you to review it, heh heh.
The Shaykh : What do you want now?
The student : Muhammad, if you are intending to shorten it, my Shaykh, replace it with one that is a bit longer.
The Shaykh : Is that it?
The student : Yes, this is instead of him unfastening it.
The Shaykh : Why?
The student : So that it is flush against the wall, what do you think? Because he wants to unfasten it, and we have pipe pieces.
Another student : ...
The student : No ... the tank is done. Now, a piece comes here, look, yes, three-quarters of it, go look at it, Muhammad, yes, it is toothed.
Another student : ...
The student : All right, okay, okay, so that...
Another student: ... so that you can bring it from behind.
The student : All right, okay, rely on Allah.
Another student: From behind this same line.
The student : All right, okay.
Another student: ... unless we bring it.
The student : Glory be to Allah, if the water were available, he would do everything quickly, but the problem is...
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
