The Criterion for the Forbidden Type of Taqlid
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : May Allah bless you. Ah, people are not all in the same category. What is this talk about forbidding taqlid? The forbidden taqlid is preferring taqlid over the explicit text of the Book and the Sunnah. As for a man who does not know, he asks the scholar in whose knowledge he has confidence.
The student : But in this context, when the Messenger of Allah said it, the jurists said it does not mean imposing it on them. So when they rejected the words of the Messenger... it has no relation... So if a person rejects the hadith in favor of his madhhab, it becomes easy for him.
Another student: This is in the category of, for example, I hit this person, in the category of taqlid, that he imitated just anyone.
The student : No, he...
Another student: ...
The student : He rejected the hadith when... he said: The saying of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him): Sunan al-Bayhaqi 4:239 ... When he was asked: "For this year only?" He said: This hadith... when they rejected the words of the Messenger with the words of Abu Bakr and Umar, this was a rejection of them. Sunan Ibn Majah 1747Sahih (Darussalam) May Allah reward you... a good opportunity, by Allah.
Another student: May Allah welcome you.
The student : ... I did not recognize you.
Another student: May Allah bless you.
The student : A good acquaintance...
Another student: ...
The student : Another student: I work in the Holy City of Madinah as an education inspector. But now...
The student : But in this context, when the Messenger of Allah said it, the jurists said it does not mean imposing it on them. So when they rejected the words of the Messenger... it has no relation... So if a person rejects the hadith in favor of his madhhab, it becomes easy for him.
Another student: This is in the category of, for example, I hit this person, in the category of taqlid, that he imitated just anyone.
The student : No, he...
Another student: ...
The student : He rejected the hadith when... he said:
Whoever performs tawaf of the House and al-Safa and al-Marwah, and has not driven the sacrificial animals, has become in the state of 'Umrah, whether he wills it or not.
مَن طاف بالبيت والصفا والمروة ، مَن لم يكن ساق الهدي فقد صارت عمرة شاء أم أبىWhoever has not driven the sacrificial animals should exit the state of ihram.
مَن لم يسق الهدي أن يحلNo, it is obligatory forever, it is obligatory forever.
بل لا بد الأبد ، لا بد الأبدAftara ‘indakumus-saimun, wa akala ta’amakumul-abrar
أفطر عندكم الصائمون ، وأكل طعامكم الأبرارAnother student: May Allah welcome you.
The student : ... I did not recognize you.
Another student: May Allah bless you.
The student : A good acquaintance...
Another student: ...
The student : Another student: I work in the Holy City of Madinah as an education inspector. But now...
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.