How to reconcile the narrations of the hadith regarding a dog drinking from a vessel
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The narration in Muslim:Sunan Ibn Majah 365Sahih (Darussalam), how do you reconcile it with the other narrations?
Answer:
The eighth, meaning: with respect to the earth, it is the eighth; otherwise, it is seven, with the eighth being the earth, which is added to one of the washings.
Q: Is it in the first one?
A: It is more preferable in the first one; due to the narration of Abu Hurayrah:, and that is better;
The narration in Muslim:
If a dog licks a vessel, wash it seven times and rub it with dust the eight times.
إذا ولغ الكلبُ في الإناء فاغسلوه سبع مراتٍ، وعَفِّروه الثامنة بالتُّرابAnswer:
The eighth, meaning: with respect to the earth, it is the eighth; otherwise, it is seven, with the eighth being the earth, which is added to one of the washings.
Q: Is it in the first one?
A: It is more preferable in the first one; due to the narration of Abu Hurayrah:
The first of them with earth.
أولاهنَّ بالتراب
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.