Does the prohibition of a thing necessitate its invalidity?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Does the prohibition of a thing necessitate its invalidity?
Answer:
A: It may necessitate invalidity, and it may not. The prohibition of selling necessitates the invalidity of the sale, and the prohibition of praying at a specific time—such as the time of prohibition—without a cause invalidates the prayer.
Q: It invalidates it?
A: Yes, if one prays during the time of prohibition without a cause, the prayer is invalid.
Q: Does the prohibition necessitate invalidity? Or does the prohibition (tahrim) necessitate invalidity?
A: Prohibition (tahrim) necessitates invalidity, except where evidence indicates that it is not prohibited and not invalid.
Does the prohibition of a thing necessitate its invalidity?
Answer:
A: It may necessitate invalidity, and it may not. The prohibition of selling necessitates the invalidity of the sale, and the prohibition of praying at a specific time—such as the time of prohibition—without a cause invalidates the prayer.
Q: It invalidates it?
A: Yes, if one prays during the time of prohibition without a cause, the prayer is invalid.
Q: Does the prohibition necessitate invalidity? Or does the prohibition (tahrim) necessitate invalidity?
A: Prohibition (tahrim) necessitates invalidity, except where evidence indicates that it is not prohibited and not invalid.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
