What is the point of similarity between the Jahmiyyah and the Murji'ah?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Are the Jahmiyyah Murji'ah in every respect?
Answer:
The Jahmiyyah hold that the servant is compelled in his actions; they are called the Mujbirah. They view the servant as compelled, with no choice. They deny the names and attributes, may Allah protect us from that, and they are disbelievers with major disbelief.
Q: Do they resemble the Murji'ah in anything?
A: It may be said that they resemble them because they say the servant is compelled and is not accountable, and their view necessitates that Allah is unjust toward them.
Q: Do they resemble the Murji'ah in their statement that faith is affirmation by the heart?
A: For them, faith is knowledge.
Are the Jahmiyyah Murji'ah in every respect?
Answer:
The Jahmiyyah hold that the servant is compelled in his actions; they are called the Mujbirah. They view the servant as compelled, with no choice. They deny the names and attributes, may Allah protect us from that, and they are disbelievers with major disbelief.
Q: Do they resemble the Murji'ah in anything?
A: It may be said that they resemble them because they say the servant is compelled and is not accountable, and their view necessitates that Allah is unjust toward them.
Q: Do they resemble the Murji'ah in their statement that faith is affirmation by the heart?
A: For them, faith is knowledge.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.