Is the prescribed practice on the festival one sermon or two?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Is the festival one sermon or two?
Answer:
The well-known view among scholars is two sermons, but in the narrations it is said: We have not seen anything but one sermon.
However, the scholars analogized it to the Friday sermon; because it is the festival of the year, and Friday is the festival of the week. A weak narration mentions two sermons, and the well-known view in the authentic hadiths is one sermon.
Q: Is it authentic?
A: It appears that the scholars attached the festival to Friday and made it two sermons like Friday; because it is the festival of the year. This is the view of the majority of scholars: that it is two sermons like Friday.
Q: Is the opinion of the majority followed?
A: That is the apparent ruling.
Q: If he delivers one sermon, is there anything upon him?
A: We do not know of anything in that. The purpose is to convey the message to the people, admonish them, and remind them. The narration that mentions two sermons contains weakness.
Q: What about the one who continues with one sermon?
A: We do not know of anything in that. I say: We do not know of anything in this matter.
Is the festival one sermon or two?
Answer:
The well-known view among scholars is two sermons, but in the narrations it is said: We have not seen anything but one sermon.
However, the scholars analogized it to the Friday sermon; because it is the festival of the year, and Friday is the festival of the week. A weak narration mentions two sermons, and the well-known view in the authentic hadiths is one sermon.
Q: Is it authentic?
A: It appears that the scholars attached the festival to Friday and made it two sermons like Friday; because it is the festival of the year. This is the view of the majority of scholars: that it is two sermons like Friday.
Q: Is the opinion of the majority followed?
A: That is the apparent ruling.
Q: If he delivers one sermon, is there anything upon him?
A: We do not know of anything in that. The purpose is to convey the message to the people, admonish them, and remind them. The narration that mentions two sermons contains weakness.
Q: What about the one who continues with one sermon?
A: We do not know of anything in that. I say: We do not know of anything in this matter.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
