The ruling on saying: "Wa I'madistama" and "Wa Islamah"
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
What is the ruling on a man saying: "Wa I'madistama" and "Wa Islamah"?
Answer:
If it is in the way of calling for aid, what is the intention? The intention of calling for aid means mentioning him... this has passed before, so this is a matter of reminder.
As for if the intention is that he is claiming the dead man, and taking the dead man as [a means], like saying: "O Zayn al-Badawi, O..." then it is major shirk (associating partners with Allah) if he leads to calling for aid from al-Mu'tasim, and asking al-Mu'tasim [for help], then this is major shirk. But if his intention is to remind of this, and he does not intend al-Mu'tasim now... and he does not intend calling for aid from al-Mu'tasim, or seeking al-Mu'tasim's help; so that he rises and rebels for this matter; because he knows that al-Mu'tasim has died, and does not possess anything for him.
What is the ruling on a man saying: "Wa I'madistama" and "Wa Islamah"?
Answer:
If it is in the way of calling for aid, what is the intention? The intention of calling for aid means mentioning him... this has passed before, so this is a matter of reminder.
As for if the intention is that he is claiming the dead man, and taking the dead man as [a means], like saying: "O Zayn al-Badawi, O..." then it is major shirk (associating partners with Allah) if he leads to calling for aid from al-Mu'tasim, and asking al-Mu'tasim [for help], then this is major shirk. But if his intention is to remind of this, and he does not intend al-Mu'tasim now... and he does not intend calling for aid from al-Mu'tasim, or seeking al-Mu'tasim's help; so that he rises and rebels for this matter; because he knows that al-Mu'tasim has died, and does not possess anything for him.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.