Evaluation of the Book al-Husun al-Mani'ah by Muhammad 'Alawi al-Maliki
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The al-Husun al-Mani'ah, compiled by Muhammad 'Alawi al-Maliki...?
Answer:
No, these al-Husun al-Mani'ah contain errors; they include some religious innovations. This 'Alawi's writings are afflicted with many religious innovations, and he is afflicted with many matters of shirk (associating partners with Allah)—may Allah grant us safety from it. He is well known in Makkah, and the scholars have alerted him to his errors and mistakes, but he persisted in his falsehood. We ask Allah to guide him and return him to the truth. He has authored works containing much evil; his al-Dhakhair al-Muhammadiyyah contains major shirk and religious innovations, and his book al-Mafahim contains many errors.
The intended point is: The point is that one should not rely on him; Muhammad ibn 'Alawi al-Maliki is not to be relied upon in his books, because he is a man who engages in absurdity and has deviation in 'aqidah (creed)—may Allah grant guidance to us and to him. Therefore, it is not permissible to rely on his books or his fatwas (scholarly legal rulings) until he returns to the truth, declares his repentance, and corrects the falsehood he has written—may Allah grant guidance to us and to him.
The al-Husun al-Mani'ah, compiled by Muhammad 'Alawi al-Maliki...?
Answer:
No, these al-Husun al-Mani'ah contain errors; they include some religious innovations. This 'Alawi's writings are afflicted with many religious innovations, and he is afflicted with many matters of shirk (associating partners with Allah)—may Allah grant us safety from it. He is well known in Makkah, and the scholars have alerted him to his errors and mistakes, but he persisted in his falsehood. We ask Allah to guide him and return him to the truth. He has authored works containing much evil; his al-Dhakhair al-Muhammadiyyah contains major shirk and religious innovations, and his book al-Mafahim contains many errors.
The intended point is: The point is that one should not rely on him; Muhammad ibn 'Alawi al-Maliki is not to be relied upon in his books, because he is a man who engages in absurdity and has deviation in 'aqidah (creed)—may Allah grant guidance to us and to him. Therefore, it is not permissible to rely on his books or his fatwas (scholarly legal rulings) until he returns to the truth, declares his repentance, and corrects the falsehood he has written—may Allah grant guidance to us and to him.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.