They stated in "Al-Asalah Magazine" that you are among the scholars who say that if the dawn breaks while the fasting person is having intercourse, he must withdraw.

The questioner : Here, if you would allow me, in the latest issue of "Al-Asalah Magazine," they mentioned you as being in agreement with the consensus that if the dawn breaks during intercourse, withdrawal is obligatory. This is by consensus. So, as I understood from my brother Muhammad about a week ago, you say something different?

The Shaykh: Yes.

The questioner : Based on the analogy of the vessel.

The Shaykh : It is so, but how did they mention this about me? Did they quote it?

The questioner : Yes, they quoted it.

The Shaykh : Did they quote it from a source, from such and such?

The questioner : No, just a passing word like that.

Another questioner : They included you with the scholars who say that withdrawal is obligatory immediately from them.

The questioner : The Shaykh, we asked him this question a long time ago, and he said: It is like the vessel, this is a vessel and this is.

Another questioner : Regarding what you issued a ruling on and what they wrote, is there a difference or not? They said: If the dawn breaks; is there a difference between the dawn breaking and the hadith: ; I mean, to be honest, they did not quote it, they said: If the dawn breaks.

The Shaykh : No, there is no difference.

The questioner : There is no difference.