A chat with the Shaykh regarding academic plagiarism.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Abu Layla: So I ... at HAY ... .
The Shaykh: The point is, we ask Allah to guide him.
Abu Layla: Excuse me - my Shaykh - , he said that he swore an oath, and even a while ago, at the end of the gathering, "Nizam" - our Shaykh - we wanted him to swear an oath before us, you said: This is between us and him now.
Another questioner: Between ... and ... .
Abu Layla: Yes, notice, I truly mean, when the Shaykh passed by, he said to me: Since he wants to swear an oath, the matter is over. I said to him: But it became clear ... - may Allah reward him with good - this thing, I must be convinced of it from any angle, I do not discuss it with you, but I remembered the hadith about Isa (peace be upon him) when he saw that one stealing, he said to him: By Allah, I did not steal, and I say like Isa (peace be upon him), meaning.
Another questioner : .
Abu Layla: Yes, but did Isa (peace be upon him) really not see him stealing?
Another questioner: He saw him stealing.
Abu Layla: But because of the oath, he accepted it, and I say.
The Shaykh : Allah is the Helper.
Another questioner: He swore ... .
Abu Layla: That this is from his composition.
The Shaykh: Meaning, his critique of the hadith, his weakening of the hadith that matches my style in its style, he had not previously encountered my critique in this style, but this is a coincidence. I said once to some of them: By Allah, this requires faith, it requires faith! Faith in the unseen, meaning; because it is above reason.
There are stories of "Juhha"; they claim that one day he entered a garden or orchard, so he started gathering fruits and stuffing them in his pockets. The guard sensed him, so he seized him and asked him: How did you get in here? He said to him: The wind blew me in. He said to him: Okay, and what about the fruits in your pocket? He said to him: By Allah, I am thinking about how, meaning? The wind blew them to this garden, but the wind put them in.
Another questioner: He is thinking!
The Shaykh: He is thinking, he said!! Yes.
The Shaykh: Yes.
The Shaykh: The point is, we ask Allah to guide him.
Abu Layla: Excuse me - my Shaykh - , he said that he swore an oath, and even a while ago, at the end of the gathering, "Nizam" - our Shaykh - we wanted him to swear an oath before us, you said: This is between us and him now.
Another questioner: Between ... and ... .
Abu Layla: Yes, notice, I truly mean, when the Shaykh passed by, he said to me: Since he wants to swear an oath, the matter is over. I said to him: But it became clear ... - may Allah reward him with good - this thing, I must be convinced of it from any angle, I do not discuss it with you, but I remembered the hadith about Isa (peace be upon him) when he saw that one stealing, he said to him: By Allah, I did not steal, and I say like Isa (peace be upon him), meaning.
Another questioner :
Whoever swears by Allah, believe him
مَن حَلَفَ بالله فصدِّقوهAbu Layla: Yes, but did Isa (peace be upon him) really not see him stealing?
Another questioner: He saw him stealing.
Abu Layla: But because of the oath, he accepted it, and I say.
The Shaykh : Allah is the Helper.
Another questioner: He swore ... .
Abu Layla: That this is from his composition.
The Shaykh: Meaning, his critique of the hadith, his weakening of the hadith that matches my style in its style, he had not previously encountered my critique in this style, but this is a coincidence. I said once to some of them: By Allah, this requires faith, it requires faith! Faith in the unseen, meaning; because it is above reason.
There are stories of "Juhha"; they claim that one day he entered a garden or orchard, so he started gathering fruits and stuffing them in his pockets. The guard sensed him, so he seized him and asked him: How did you get in here? He said to him: The wind blew me in. He said to him: Okay, and what about the fruits in your pocket? He said to him: By Allah, I am thinking about how, meaning? The wind blew them to this garden, but the wind put them in.
Another questioner: He is thinking!
The Shaykh: He is thinking, he said!! Yes.
The Shaykh: Yes.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.