It is not said: "We met with him" or "We met with him"; rather, it is said: "We met him"; because it is transitive in itself.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Abu Malik: ... So it is not said: "We met with him," nor "We met with him"; rather, this is not transitive by means of a preposition, but it is transitive in itself.
The questioner : I said: "We met with him."
Abu Malik: "We met him."
The questioner : ... He said: "I met with him" ...
Abu Malik: Linguistically, linguistically, it is a linguistic error.
Abu Layla : Meaning, it is transitive in itself; there is no need for anything to make it transitive; because it is ...
Abu Malik: Transitivity, yes.
Al-Halabi : "I met him" is transitive in itself.
The Shaykh : Transitive in its essence.
Abu Malik: "I met him" is exactly as you said, like "we met," for example.
The questioner : Yes?
Abu Malik: "We met," for example.
The questioner : ... .
Abu Malik: It is not said: "I met so-and-so," or it is said: "We met each other."
The questioner : Meaning, do I not say: "I met with so-and-so"?
Abu Malik: No, it is not said.
The questioner : "I met so-and-so," for example.
Abu Malik: Yes, yes.
The questioner : May Allah reward you with good.
Abu Malik: And you as well.
The questioner : ... And so on, meaning we warn them that they are veiling themselves by covering their hair ... meaning they wear something like an abaya or something ... I do not know, I mean, O Shaykh, are these disbelievers obligated, as long as they are in the land of the Muslims ...?
Another questioner : ... May Allah guide you, you are wasting our time.
The questioner : No, but...
The Shaykh : The land is inhabited now!
Another questioner : That is the answer, we asked your question ... the Shaykh.
The questioner: All right.
Abu Layla : From the beginning only.
The Shaykh : No, no, he does not want ...
Abu Layla : ... Our Shaykh, we will arrange it, if Allah wills, before ...
The Shaykh : You frightened me, let alone others.
Those present : [Everyone laughs!]
Al-Halabi : O our Shaykh, we are accustomed to it.
The questioner : I said: "We met with him."
Abu Malik: "We met him."
The questioner : ... He said: "I met with him" ...
Abu Malik: Linguistically, linguistically, it is a linguistic error.
Abu Layla : Meaning, it is transitive in itself; there is no need for anything to make it transitive; because it is ...
Abu Malik: Transitivity, yes.
Al-Halabi : "I met him" is transitive in itself.
The Shaykh : Transitive in its essence.
Abu Malik: "I met him" is exactly as you said, like "we met," for example.
The questioner : Yes?
Abu Malik: "We met," for example.
The questioner : ... .
Abu Malik: It is not said: "I met so-and-so," or it is said: "We met each other."
The questioner : Meaning, do I not say: "I met with so-and-so"?
Abu Malik: No, it is not said.
The questioner : "I met so-and-so," for example.
Abu Malik: Yes, yes.
The questioner : May Allah reward you with good.
Abu Malik: And you as well.
The questioner : ... And so on, meaning we warn them that they are veiling themselves by covering their hair ... meaning they wear something like an abaya or something ... I do not know, I mean, O Shaykh, are these disbelievers obligated, as long as they are in the land of the Muslims ...?
Another questioner : ... May Allah guide you, you are wasting our time.
The questioner : No, but...
The Shaykh : The land is inhabited now!
Another questioner : That is the answer, we asked your question ... the Shaykh.
The questioner: All right.
Abu Layla : From the beginning only.
The Shaykh : No, no, he does not want ...
Abu Layla : ... Our Shaykh, we will arrange it, if Allah wills, before ...
The Shaykh : You frightened me, let alone others.
Those present : [Everyone laughs!]
Al-Halabi : O our Shaykh, we are accustomed to it.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
