Permissibility of returning to Mina for one who left it early if he has a need there
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Permissibility of returning to Mina for one who left it early if he has a need there
I left Mina on the second day of Tashreeq before the sun set. When I went to Makkah, I lost one of my companions, so I returned to Mina to look for him after the sun had set—after the 'Isha' prayer. Do I owe anything?
You owe nothing; because if a person leaves Mina before the sun sets on the twelfth day, he has left early. If he returns to Mina to fulfill a need, or because it is his route and path, or to check on one of his brothers, there is nothing wrong with it.
I left Mina on the second day of Tashreeq before the sun set. When I went to Makkah, I lost one of my companions, so I returned to Mina to look for him after the sun had set—after the 'Isha' prayer. Do I owe anything?
You owe nothing; because if a person leaves Mina before the sun sets on the twelfth day, he has left early. If he returns to Mina to fulfill a need, or because it is his route and path, or to check on one of his brothers, there is nothing wrong with it.