Prohibition of Prohibition and Prohibition of Dislike
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
How do I know whether a hadith of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) regarding prohibition is for the purpose of prohibition (making it haram) or for the purpose of dislike (making it makruh)?
There is no general rule,And although some scholars said: The default ruling for prohibition is that it is haram, and we do not deviate from this except with evidence,And some said: The default ruling for prohibition is that it is disliked, and we do not declare it haram except with evidence,And some of them distinguished and said: The default ruling in acts of worship is that prohibition is for the purpose of making it haram, and in morals and etiquette, prohibition is for the purpose of guidance and dislike,Meaning: Guidance to leave it and dislike of doing it, but after we have given it thought and reflection, we have not found a settled rule, so each text is judged by what it requires and by the legal indicators from other evidence.
There is no general rule,And although some scholars said: The default ruling for prohibition is that it is haram, and we do not deviate from this except with evidence,And some said: The default ruling for prohibition is that it is disliked, and we do not declare it haram except with evidence,And some of them distinguished and said: The default ruling in acts of worship is that prohibition is for the purpose of making it haram, and in morals and etiquette, prohibition is for the purpose of guidance and dislike,Meaning: Guidance to leave it and dislike of doing it, but after we have given it thought and reflection, we have not found a settled rule, so each text is judged by what it requires and by the legal indicators from other evidence.