The one performing tamattu': if he performs tawaf and then throws the pebbles, does he exit the first state of ihram?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : He says: The one performing tamattu', if he performs tawaf. He says: The one performing tamattu', if he performs tawaf and then throws the pebbles, does he exit the first state of ihram?
The Shaykh : According to the jurists (may Allah have mercy on them), the first exit from ihram occurs when one throws the pebbles and performs tawaf, because they say: the first exit from ihram is achieved by doing two of three things. And they are throwing the pebbles, shaving the head, and tawaf. But the Sunnah indicates that there is no exit from ihram except by throwing the pebbles and shaving the head. And based on this, we say: the first exit from ihram is achieved by throwing the pebbles and shaving the head only. And if one throws the pebbles and performs tawaf, the first exit from ihram is not achieved except according to the opinion of those who hold that throwing the pebbles alone achieves the first exit from ihram. Yes.
The Shaykh : According to the jurists (may Allah have mercy on them), the first exit from ihram occurs when one throws the pebbles and performs tawaf, because they say: the first exit from ihram is achieved by doing two of three things. And they are throwing the pebbles, shaving the head, and tawaf. But the Sunnah indicates that there is no exit from ihram except by throwing the pebbles and shaving the head. And based on this, we say: the first exit from ihram is achieved by throwing the pebbles and shaving the head only. And if one throws the pebbles and performs tawaf, the first exit from ihram is not achieved except according to the opinion of those who hold that throwing the pebbles alone achieves the first exit from ihram. Yes.