The ruling on one who stoned the pillars and performed tawaf without shaving
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
How authentic is the saying that is attributed: Whoever performs two of the three has exited the state of ihram.
Does one exit the state of ihram by stoning the pillars and performing tawaf without shaving or shortening the hair?
Many scholars hold that the first exit from ihram is achieved by stoning the pillars alone,Meaning: specifically by stoning the Jamrat al-Aqabah on the day of Eid, but it appears that one does not exit the state of ihram except by stoning the pillars and shaving the head,And as for the famous phrase among the jurists: that the first exit from ihram is achieved by performing two of the three, which are stoning the pillars, shaving the head, and performing tawaf. I do not know of any Sunnah regarding this, but there is analogical reasoning and consideration; because tawaf has an effect on the second exit from ihram, if it has an effect on the second exit, it has an effect on the first exit.According to the words of the jurists: If one stoned the pillars and performed tawaf, the first exit from ihram is achieved even if he did not shave. If he shaved and performed tawaf, the first exit from ihram is achieved even if he did not stone the pillars. If he stoned the pillars and shaved, the first exit from ihram is achieved even if he did not perform tawaf.
Does one exit the state of ihram by stoning the pillars and performing tawaf without shaving or shortening the hair?
Many scholars hold that the first exit from ihram is achieved by stoning the pillars alone,Meaning: specifically by stoning the Jamrat al-Aqabah on the day of Eid, but it appears that one does not exit the state of ihram except by stoning the pillars and shaving the head,And as for the famous phrase among the jurists: that the first exit from ihram is achieved by performing two of the three, which are stoning the pillars, shaving the head, and performing tawaf. I do not know of any Sunnah regarding this, but there is analogical reasoning and consideration; because tawaf has an effect on the second exit from ihram, if it has an effect on the second exit, it has an effect on the first exit.According to the words of the jurists: If one stoned the pillars and performed tawaf, the first exit from ihram is achieved even if he did not shave. If he shaved and performed tawaf, the first exit from ihram is achieved even if he did not stone the pillars. If he stoned the pillars and shaved, the first exit from ihram is achieved even if he did not perform tawaf.