Is it permissible to stone the pillars on behalf of women due to the crowd?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Is it permissible to stone the pillars on behalf of women who are able to walk, due to the crowd?
The Shaykh : Stoning the pillars on behalf of women who are able to walk, due to the crowd, is not permissible. No, it is not permissible. If we assume that they are with their mahrams, the mahrams surround them and protect them. So if we assume that she performs Hajj as some of those ignorant women do, without a mahram, then she has brought the harm upon herself. No, it is not permissible... Here, without her mahram, he surrounds her and repels the harm of the crowd from her.
The questioner : Okay...
The Shaykh : I have no answer to this question, because I... Yes.
The Shaykh : Stoning the pillars on behalf of women who are able to walk, due to the crowd, is not permissible. No, it is not permissible. If we assume that they are with their mahrams, the mahrams surround them and protect them. So if we assume that she performs Hajj as some of those ignorant women do, without a mahram, then she has brought the harm upon herself. No, it is not permissible... Here, without her mahram, he surrounds her and repels the harm of the crowd from her.
The questioner : Okay...
The Shaykh : I have no answer to this question, because I... Yes.