Discussion of Shaykh Rabi'’s book in his response to the book *Sifat al-Ghurba* by Salman al-'Udah, his distinction between the victorious group and the saved sect, and his criticism
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh: If Allah wills, and what are the books?
'Abd al-Malik: A book on *Sifat al-Ghurba* by Dr. Salman al-'Udah, who is a young Saudi, and in it he distinguishes between the victorious group and the saved sect
The Shaykh : Yes.
'Abd al-Malik: And he mentions there some of what he criticizes the Salafis for
The Shaykh: Did you read the book?
'Abd al-Malik: I only read the paragraphs from it
The Shaykh: What does he mean by distinguishing between the victorious group and the saved sect?
'Abd al-Malik: He says that the saved sect is broader than the victorious group, and that this saved sect is not more specific to the people of hadith; this is approximately a summary of his words
The Shaykh : Ah
'Abd al-Malik: And there is criticism of the Salafis for not doing independent legal reasoning except in hadithic and scholarly issues, that they have spiritual harshness and distance from worship, and that they are occupied with responding to the misguided sects while remaining silent about the secularists or what is now called the realistic sects
The Shaykh : Yes.
'Abd al-Malik: And he also complainsThe Shaykh : Rabi' about these people for slandering the shaykhs by saying they lack understanding of reality; this is a summary of what came. If you wish to speak on the topic, I have questions that I have divided into jurisprudential questions and methodological questions. If you wish to follow this path, let us follow the methodological questions; otherwise, postpone it according to your discretion or after you have read these
The Shaykh: Now, have you looked at the books?
onAl-Halabi: I have looked, by Allah, O our Shaykh, at the words he mentioned
The Shaykh: No, I mean the books
'Ali: Yes, I saw them
The Shaykh: Are they available?
'Ali: They are available, yes
'Abd al-Malik: And some of the tapes as well
The Shaykh: Okay, they must be studied
'Abd al-Malik: If so, yes
The Shaykh: It is postponed.
'Abd al-Malik: A book on *Sifat al-Ghurba* by Dr. Salman al-'Udah, who is a young Saudi, and in it he distinguishes between the victorious group and the saved sect
The Shaykh : Yes.
'Abd al-Malik: And he mentions there some of what he criticizes the Salafis for
The Shaykh: Did you read the book?
'Abd al-Malik: I only read the paragraphs from it
The Shaykh: What does he mean by distinguishing between the victorious group and the saved sect?
'Abd al-Malik: He says that the saved sect is broader than the victorious group, and that this saved sect is not more specific to the people of hadith; this is approximately a summary of his words
The Shaykh : Ah
'Abd al-Malik: And there is criticism of the Salafis for not doing independent legal reasoning except in hadithic and scholarly issues, that they have spiritual harshness and distance from worship, and that they are occupied with responding to the misguided sects while remaining silent about the secularists or what is now called the realistic sects
The Shaykh : Yes.
'Abd al-Malik: And he also complainsThe Shaykh : Rabi' about these people for slandering the shaykhs by saying they lack understanding of reality; this is a summary of what came. If you wish to speak on the topic, I have questions that I have divided into jurisprudential questions and methodological questions. If you wish to follow this path, let us follow the methodological questions; otherwise, postpone it according to your discretion or after you have read these
The Shaykh: Now, have you looked at the books?
onAl-Halabi: I have looked, by Allah, O our Shaykh, at the words he mentioned
The Shaykh: No, I mean the books
'Ali: Yes, I saw them
The Shaykh: Are they available?
'Ali: They are available, yes
'Abd al-Malik: And some of the tapes as well
The Shaykh: Okay, they must be studied
'Abd al-Malik: If so, yes
The Shaykh: It is postponed.
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.