Discussion between students of knowledge and Shaykh Al-Albani regarding the hadith of Aisha when the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) ordered her to go out to al-Hal for 'Umrah after
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: 'Umrah and Hajj.
The questioner : ... .
Another questioner : ... ؟
The Shaykh: The scholarly consensus that appears in the authentic hadith which has no contradicting evidence ... regarding the invalidity of their going.
Another questioner: ... so one must go out in a state of ihram ... and cites as evidence the hadith of Aisha ... .
The Shaykh : ... .
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Whoever wants Hajj and 'Umrah, this is qiran, this is bringing it forward. If we interpret the hadith with this interpretation, the one who says ... for exampleMusannaf Abd al-Razzaq 4:415 because it came as qiran, it includes this issue ... .
Another questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: ... No, it is not so. The hadith of Aisha is about a menstruating woman ... so how do you compare men who do not menstruate ... Is that so, Aisha? Did anyone from the masses of the Companions perform 'Umrah with Aisha? Did anyone from the Companions of the Messenger perform 'Umrah with Aisha from al-Tan'im in the Farewell Pilgrimage?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: This is not an answer ... and my understanding is a question I direct to him.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: For example, one says: The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said:Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah 22:637 and so on ... Did any of the Companions say, did anyone do that? My brother, as long as the Messenger pointed to this ... .
The questioner: ... the command to Aisha.
The Shaykh: My brother, why did he command Aisha? Why did he command Aisha to perform 'Umrah when she had previously intended 'Umrah ... by the command of the Messenger (peace be upon him)? And he came in to her while she was crying and said:. She said: The people are returning with Hajj and 'Umrah, and I am returning with only Hajj!! So he said to her: and so on.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: It is not up to you.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: I am telling you, the Messenger of Allah said it is not up to you.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: ... before 'Arafah and menstruation will come to you ... No, this is the reality.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: ... This is not the issue. I am telling you this: if you are convinced, then fine; if you are not convinced ... none of the Companions performed 'Umrah with her. So if it were obedience to Allah and obedience to His Messenger for the one who combined Hajj and 'Umrah, either by the way of tamattu' or by the way of qiran, to go out again to al-Hal from al-Tan'im, if it were recommended for him to go out again to al-Hal from al-Tan'im, one of the Companions of the Messenger, who are counted in thousands, would have done it. But here ... so there is a Muslim man created by Allah as a sound man and preferred over women ... 'Umrah, because she had a special situation: she menstruated and did not perform tamattu', she was unable to perform 'Umrah, so the Messenger (peace be upon him) permitted her 'Umrah ... he took her out to al-Tan'im ... the Messenger (peace be upon him) [said] that everyone who passes by these miqat points who wants Hajj and 'Umrah must enter ihram from there, not from Makkah, not enter ihram here from Makkah ... for everyone who wants Hajj and 'Umrah ... that we speak of its ta'wil, qiran for another issue and hold onto it ... with menstruating women, yes.
Another questioner: Regarding ... when he went out ... 'Umrah from al-Tan'im.
The Shaykh: When?
The questioner: ... goes out from al-Tan'im and performs his 'Umrah ... .
The Shaykh: 'Umrah and Hajj.
The questioner : ... .
Another questioner : ... ؟
The Shaykh: The scholarly consensus that appears in the authentic hadith which has no contradicting evidence ... regarding the invalidity of their going.
Another questioner: ... so one must go out in a state of ihram ... and cites as evidence the hadith of Aisha ... .
The Shaykh : ... .
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Whoever wants Hajj and 'Umrah, this is qiran, this is bringing it forward. If we interpret the hadith with this interpretation, the one who says ... for example
Whoever performed ghusl and bathed, and went out early and started early ...
مَن غسَّلَ واغتسل ، وبكَّرَ وابتكر ...Another questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: ... No, it is not so. The hadith of Aisha is about a menstruating woman ... so how do you compare men who do not menstruate ... Is that so, Aisha? Did anyone from the masses of the Companions perform 'Umrah with Aisha? Did anyone from the Companions of the Messenger perform 'Umrah with Aisha from al-Tan'im in the Farewell Pilgrimage?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: This is not an answer ... and my understanding is a question I direct to him.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: For example, one says: The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
Whoever heard the call and then said: O Allah, Lord of this perfect call and the established prayer
مَن سمع نداء ثم قال : اللهم ربَّ هذه الدعوة التامة والصلاة القائمةMy intercession is permitted for him
حلَّت له شفاعتيThe questioner: ... the command to Aisha.
The Shaykh: My brother, why did he command Aisha? Why did he command Aisha to perform 'Umrah when she had previously intended 'Umrah ... by the command of the Messenger (peace be upon him)? And he came in to her while she was crying and said:
What is wrong with you?
ما بك ؟Go out to al-Tan'im
اخرجي إلى التنعيمThe questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: It is not up to you.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: I am telling you, the Messenger of Allah said it is not up to you.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: ... before 'Arafah and menstruation will come to you ... No, this is the reality.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: ... This is not the issue. I am telling you this: if you are convinced, then fine; if you are not convinced ... none of the Companions performed 'Umrah with her. So if it were obedience to Allah and obedience to His Messenger for the one who combined Hajj and 'Umrah, either by the way of tamattu' or by the way of qiran, to go out again to al-Hal from al-Tan'im, if it were recommended for him to go out again to al-Hal from al-Tan'im, one of the Companions of the Messenger, who are counted in thousands, would have done it. But here ... so there is a Muslim man created by Allah as a sound man and preferred over women ... 'Umrah, because she had a special situation: she menstruated and did not perform tamattu', she was unable to perform 'Umrah, so the Messenger (peace be upon him) permitted her 'Umrah ... he took her out to al-Tan'im ... the Messenger (peace be upon him) [said] that everyone who passes by these miqat points who wants Hajj and 'Umrah must enter ihram from there, not from Makkah, not enter ihram here from Makkah ... for everyone who wants Hajj and 'Umrah ... that we speak of its ta'wil, qiran for another issue and hold onto it ... with menstruating women, yes.
Another questioner: Regarding ... when he went out ... 'Umrah from al-Tan'im.
The Shaykh: When?
The questioner: ... goes out from al-Tan'im and performs his 'Umrah ... .
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.