Does this disagreement lead to disagreement in the rulings of Islamic law?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Abu Malik: And we say that this knowledge, whether it is a matter of ease, that if the hadiths are either ahad (limited chain) or mutawatir (mass-transmitted), do they affect the methodology that we believe in, deem correct, and call people to? They affect the beliefs in terms of priority or delay, or validity or invalidity? This does not affect it at all. Therefore, the reality, as our Shaykh said, is that there is no fruit. Even if this disagreement is found, there is no fruit brought or guaranteed from this disagreement that they claim. But there is a very serious issue. If you allow me, the serious issue for me is that this statement or this distinction actually opens a wide door of evil. I do not say it is for the sake of casting doubt onThe Shaykh : Al-Albani. The Shaykh, Al-Albani, was often targeted with the arrows of the envious and the hateful, and so on. But I also say that it leads to the entry of evil upon the early Imams under the claim, "Peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah."
The Shaykh : Peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah.
Abu Malik: And with this claim, then this also leads, over time, to casting doubt on the heads of this knowledge and its Imams, criticizing them, and attacking them. We have recently heard something of this that I did not think would happen when we heard that some of them cast doubt on someone likeThe Shaykh : Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani and Imam al-Nawawi and others of the Imams of this great science. So I say, the truth is that we are harboring a great evil if we leave this matter unaddressed. Rather, we must hasten to repel it and keep it away from this noble science, which grows and increases and becomes greater every day at the hands of the distinguished scholars who are well-versed in this science, and at their head is our Shaykh, may Allah reward him with good.
The Shaykh : Imagine, but he claims to be a Salafi, and I do not actually know him, but we ask the one who knows him: Is it not at least that he claims to be a Salafi?
The questioner : He is, and those with him are.
The Shaykh : And those with him. So they are Salafis, but the one who is an innovator in this call, this destroys the entire religion. There is smoke in it, there is smoke. I mean, the problem is a very difficult one. Our knowledge now is not purified, upbringing is completely absent, and thus we are living on mere... And Allah, there is an awakening. This is not denied. There is an awakening, there is an awakening, but this is the awakening of the sleeper who has woken up and it will take time for him to regain his memory, his mind, and his wisdom completely. Please, what did you want to say?
The Shaykh : Peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah.
Abu Malik: And with this claim, then this also leads, over time, to casting doubt on the heads of this knowledge and its Imams, criticizing them, and attacking them. We have recently heard something of this that I did not think would happen when we heard that some of them cast doubt on someone likeThe Shaykh : Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani and Imam al-Nawawi and others of the Imams of this great science. So I say, the truth is that we are harboring a great evil if we leave this matter unaddressed. Rather, we must hasten to repel it and keep it away from this noble science, which grows and increases and becomes greater every day at the hands of the distinguished scholars who are well-versed in this science, and at their head is our Shaykh, may Allah reward him with good.
The Shaykh : Imagine, but he claims to be a Salafi, and I do not actually know him, but we ask the one who knows him: Is it not at least that he claims to be a Salafi?
The questioner : He is, and those with him are.
The Shaykh : And those with him. So they are Salafis, but the one who is an innovator in this call, this destroys the entire religion. There is smoke in it, there is smoke. I mean, the problem is a very difficult one. Our knowledge now is not purified, upbringing is completely absent, and thus we are living on mere... And Allah, there is an awakening. This is not denied. There is an awakening, there is an awakening, but this is the awakening of the sleeper who has woken up and it will take time for him to regain his memory, his mind, and his wisdom completely. Please, what did you want to say?
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
