And knowledge among you is attained by other means *** by the garbage of thoughts and minds (Clarification of knowledge among the people of innovation)
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"And knowledge among you is attained by other means *** by the garbage of thoughts and minds"
Who is the knowledge among you addressing? It addresses all the people of denial of the divine attributes. It says: Knowledge is attained by means other than these three proofs, which are: the Book, the Sunnah, and the statements of the Companions.
It is attained by other means, yes. "By the garbage of thoughts and minds" Garbage is the place where dirt, filth, and impurities are thrown.
"You called it decisive rational proofs" What comes after that? One person is speaking.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : I have the denial of the apparent meanings, right? It denies them.
"You called it decisive rational proofs" Meaning, this garbage, the garbage of thoughts, they called it decisive rational proofs.
It denies the apparent meanings, which carry meanings, meaning it denies the apparent sense. Therefore, they say: The apparent meaning of the texts regarding the attributes is not intended.
Who is the knowledge among you addressing? It addresses all the people of denial of the divine attributes. It says: Knowledge is attained by means other than these three proofs, which are: the Book, the Sunnah, and the statements of the Companions.
It is attained by other means, yes. "By the garbage of thoughts and minds" Garbage is the place where dirt, filth, and impurities are thrown.
"You called it decisive rational proofs" What comes after that? One person is speaking.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : I have the denial of the apparent meanings, right? It denies them.
"You called it decisive rational proofs" Meaning, this garbage, the garbage of thoughts, they called it decisive rational proofs.
It denies the apparent meanings, which carry meanings, meaning it denies the apparent sense. Therefore, they say: The apparent meaning of the texts regarding the attributes is not intended.