(The Third Comparison) And likewise, I said that your Lord is in the heavens *** or you implied a space for the Creator of the worlds. The correct statement is that He *** is above the heavens, the Sovereign of the Sovereignty.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"And likewise, I said that your Lord is in the heavens *** or you implied a space for the Creator of the worlds"
Look, now, he is addressing the Messenger when he said that Allah is in the heavens. He says this is wrong. What is the correct statement? It was
"The correct statement is that it should be said that He *** is above the heavens, the Sovereign of the Sovereignty"
What is in the heavens? His sovereignty. As for Him, no, you do not say that Allah is in the heavens; you say His sovereignty is in the heavens. So, did you err in your expression or not? You erred in your expression and did not give justice. Look, it is exactly similar to the position of the Khawarij. Yes.
Look, now, he is addressing the Messenger when he said that Allah is in the heavens. He says this is wrong. What is the correct statement? It was
"The correct statement is that it should be said that He *** is above the heavens, the Sovereign of the Sovereignty"
What is in the heavens? His sovereignty. As for Him, no, you do not say that Allah is in the heavens; you say His sovereignty is in the heavens. So, did you err in your expression or not? You erred in your expression and did not give justice. Look, it is exactly similar to the position of the Khawarij. Yes.