The hadith mentioning their life in their graves *** for what is authentic and the apparent denial, so look at the chain of narration to know its status *** if you have knowledge of this matter (Reading from
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"And the hadith mentioning their life in their graves *** for what is authentic and the apparent denial
So look at the chain of narration to know its status *** if you have knowledge of this matter"
It means there is a hadith that they are alive in their graves, but Ibn al-Qayyim says that it is not authentic and that it does not follow from the return of the soul at the time of greeting that it remains settled in the body permanently. Do you have the commentary? Yes, and what does it say?
The reader: "... the hadith in which the life of the Prophets in their graves is mentioned ... a Prophet ... in the morning until his soul is returned to him. Ibn Hibban narrated it from Anas as marfu' and said about it that it is invalid, as Abu al-Fadl Ibn al-Jawzi mentioned in al-Mawdu'at. Al-Tabarani and Abu Nu'aym also included it in al-Hilyah, and al-Bayhaqi narrated it in his book on the Life of the Prophets and narrated several corroborating narrations for it, but nothing of all that is authentic. Whoever looks at their chains of narration and has knowledge of the conditions of chains and narrators will know the status of this narration"
The Shaykh : Well done, good.
So look at the chain of narration to know its status *** if you have knowledge of this matter"
It means there is a hadith that they are alive in their graves, but Ibn al-Qayyim says that it is not authentic and that it does not follow from the return of the soul at the time of greeting that it remains settled in the body permanently. Do you have the commentary? Yes, and what does it say?
The reader: "... the hadith in which the life of the Prophets in their graves is mentioned ... a Prophet ... in the morning until his soul is returned to him. Ibn Hibban narrated it from Anas as marfu' and said about it that it is invalid, as Abu al-Fadl Ibn al-Jawzi mentioned in al-Mawdu'at. Al-Tabarani and Abu Nu'aym also included it in al-Hilyah, and al-Bayhaqi narrated it in his book on the Life of the Prophets and narrated several corroborating narrations for it, but nothing of all that is authentic. Whoever looks at their chains of narration and has knowledge of the conditions of chains and narrators will know the status of this narration"
The Shaykh : Well done, good.