Combining the hadith of twenty-five degrees and the hadith of twenty-seven degrees by stating that the former is specific to the secret prayer and the latter is specific to the loud prayer: is there a basis for this?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Those who combined the two hadiths, the hadith of the prayer having twenty-five degrees and the hadith of twenty-seven degrees, said that the prayer of twenty-five degrees is in the Dhuhr and Asr prayers, or in the secret prayers, while the twenty-seven degrees are in the loud prayers, and they brought this forward
The Shaykh : with evidence.
The questioner : That is, they said they counted twenty-five actions in the secret prayer and added two things in the loud prayer, which are saying "Ameen" with the imam and listening to the recitation.
The Shaykh : I say there is no basis for this, because the hadiths are general, and a person is not safe unless he says, "This is the favor of Allah; may Allah the Exalted increase His servants in good and favor."
The Shaykh : with evidence.
The questioner : That is, they said they counted twenty-five actions in the secret prayer and added two things in the loud prayer, which are saying "Ameen" with the imam and listening to the recitation.
The Shaykh : I say there is no basis for this, because the hadiths are general, and a person is not safe unless he says, "This is the favor of Allah; may Allah the Exalted increase His servants in good and favor."