Is a sacrificial animal required for one who neglects an obligatory act or commits a prohibited act?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Is a sacrificial animal required for one who neglects an obligatory act or commits a prohibited act?
The Shaykh : What does "required" mean?
The questioner : Some muftis say, "You owe a sacrificial animal"?
The Shaykh : For everything?
The questioner : Yes
The Shaykh : For example, if one did not know, in a matter where there is no fidyah at all, such as the marriage contract, which has no fidyah whatsoever, or the proposal to a mahram.
The questioner : Regarding neglecting an obligatory act, they say a sacrificial animal is due according to the jurists, and regarding a prohibited act, they say a fidyah is due?
Answer: We mentioned to you that the prohibited acts are divided into four categories. Did this pass by you or not?
The students: Yes.
The questioner : But regarding neglecting an obligatory act, did the Prophet...
The Shaykh : Yes, neglecting the stay at Muzdalifah or the stoning of the pillars.
The questioner : Is a sacrificial animal due for that?
The Shaykh : A sacrificial animal is due according to the jurists. Are you finished? Jumu'ah.
The Shaykh : What does "required" mean?
The questioner : Some muftis say, "You owe a sacrificial animal"?
The Shaykh : For everything?
The questioner : Yes
The Shaykh : For example, if one did not know, in a matter where there is no fidyah at all, such as the marriage contract, which has no fidyah whatsoever, or the proposal to a mahram.
The questioner : Regarding neglecting an obligatory act, they say a sacrificial animal is due according to the jurists, and regarding a prohibited act, they say a fidyah is due?
Answer: We mentioned to you that the prohibited acts are divided into four categories. Did this pass by you or not?
The students: Yes.
The questioner : But regarding neglecting an obligatory act, did the Prophet...
The Shaykh : Yes, neglecting the stay at Muzdalifah or the stoning of the pillars.
The questioner : Is a sacrificial animal due for that?
The Shaykh : A sacrificial animal is due according to the jurists. Are you finished? Jumu'ah.