What is the ruling on saying "Ameen" in the quiet prayers?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh ... Is it permissible to say "Ameen" in the quiet rak'ahs?
The Shaykh : What?
The questioner : Ameen.
The Shaykh : Ameen?
The questioner : ... al-Fatihah
The Shaykh : In the quiet prayers, one says: Ameen, but one does not raise one's voice with it.
The questioner : Does that mean he says Ameen or ...?
The Shaykh : When he finishes al-Fatihah, he says: Ameen in both the quiet and the loud prayers, but he does not raise his voice with it in the quiet prayers, and he raises his voice with it in the loud prayers.
And Brother Musa is now indicating that the time has ended; it has ended, and Brother Musa is the one in charge of the recording, and it has ended.
The questioner : ... It may be that a lot of questions occur, O Shaykh, when the adhan is called.
The Shaykh : When the brothers call the adhan, but it does not exceed one minute.
The questioner : One minute.
The Shaykh : Now, please go ahead.
The Shaykh : What?
The questioner : Ameen.
The Shaykh : Ameen?
The questioner : ... al-Fatihah
The Shaykh : In the quiet prayers, one says: Ameen, but one does not raise one's voice with it.
The questioner : Does that mean he says Ameen or ...?
The Shaykh : When he finishes al-Fatihah, he says: Ameen in both the quiet and the loud prayers, but he does not raise his voice with it in the quiet prayers, and he raises his voice with it in the loud prayers.
And Brother Musa is now indicating that the time has ended; it has ended, and Brother Musa is the one in charge of the recording, and it has ended.
The questioner : ... It may be that a lot of questions occur, O Shaykh, when the adhan is called.
The Shaykh : When the brothers call the adhan, but it does not exceed one minute.
The questioner : One minute.
The Shaykh : Now, please go ahead.