If a person in the state of ihram assists a non-ihram person in hunting, does the prohibition apply to all of them?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : If a person in the state of ihram assists a non-ihram person in hunting, does the prohibition apply to all of them?
The Shaykh : No, if he participated in killing it, it is forbidden for all of them. But if he merely assisted, it is forbidden only for the one who assisted.
The questioner : If he participated in killing it, it is forbidden for all of them. If he assisted him or pointed it out to him, it is forbidden only for him. If a questioner asked, what is the distinction between the two?
The Shaykh : The distinction is that if he participated, he directly carried out the killing. If he assisted, he was only the cause. And if a cause and a direct actor are present, the liability falls on the direct actor.
The Shaykh : No, if he participated in killing it, it is forbidden for all of them. But if he merely assisted, it is forbidden only for the one who assisted.
The questioner : If he participated in killing it, it is forbidden for all of them. If he assisted him or pointed it out to him, it is forbidden only for him. If a questioner asked, what is the distinction between the two?
The Shaykh : The distinction is that if he participated, he directly carried out the killing. If he assisted, he was only the cause. And if a cause and a direct actor are present, the liability falls on the direct actor.